Topic
Every decision we've filed under Standing.
The Eleventh Circuit vacated a district court ruling that struck down a portion of Atlanta's 1982 sign code. The appellate court held that the specific provision at issue was content-neutral under the First Amendment.
The Eighth Circuit affirmed the denial of a preliminary injunction brought by a group seeking to exclude transgender athletes from girls' sports. The court held that Title IX does not provide a private right of action for claims based on disparate impact rather than intentional discrimination.
The Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court's application of Younger abstention for most claims but reversed the dismissal of a First Amendment retaliation claim. The court held that while ongoing state proceedings generally preclude federal intervention, the unique nature of the retaliation injury created an exceptional circumstance allowing the federal case to proceed on that specific issue.
The Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court's application of Younger abstention for most claims while the plaintiffs had ongoing state proceedings, but reversed the dismissal of specific First Amendment retaliation claims. The court remanded the retaliation claims for adjudication because they were sufficiently separable from the state enforcement actions and did not pose a risk of enjoining those proceedings.
The Fifth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a constitutional challenge to a Texas statute limiting marriage solemnization to religious officials or judges. The court held that the plaintiff lacked Article III standing because he failed to allege concrete plans to perform a wedding ceremony in the county.
The Tenth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a challenge to a federal agency's approval of an underground coal mine expansion. The court held that the plaintiffs failed to establish standing or a valid cause of action under the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act.
The Tenth Circuit affirmed the denial of Jvan Jackson's motion to suppress evidence from three warrantless vehicle searches. The court held that Jackson lacked Fourth Amendment standing for the first search but that officers had reasonable suspicion and probable cause for the subsequent two stops.
The Eleventh Circuit dismissed a pro se appeal filed by Jutaurio Clemons as duplicative of a previously pending appeal regarding his conviction and sentencing. The court held that Clemons lacks standing to challenge a post-judgment forfeiture order because his interest in the property was extinguished by the earlier preliminary order.
The Federal Circuit dismissed two appeals because the claimants lacked standing after the Board of Veterans' Appeals voluntarily granted them full relief. The court held that once the Board resolved all disputed issues, no live controversy remained to support appellate authority under Article III.
The D.C. Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a challenge to the State Department's handling of Diversity Immigrant Visa applications for fiscal year 2021. The court held that federal courts lack the authority to order the agency to adjudicate visas after the statutory fiscal year has expired, rendering such claims moot and lacking standing.